Hagerty.com

Question of the week: Which retro-designed modern muscle car is your favorite?


#21

09 shelby KR. The one and only.


#22

NO CONTEST…Challenger


#23

@hank46052 - That looks SHARP in that maroon color. Nice car!


#24

Thank you!
Really enjoy this car.


#25

The 2012 Mustang is my favourite. I own a V6 convertible. It is a great car to drive and the looks are fantastic. Triple Black with over 300 hp it is just a great car. My next favourite would be the Challenger with the Camaro way behind.


#26

They nailed it with the Challenger and the Mustang just keeps getting better. Chevy had the perfect opportunity to knock it out of the park and bring back the 67-69 Camaro and instead they came out with the transformer that looks like a bad chop job


#27

That’s a beauty, love the octane red with the saddle type interior. I have a Black 69 Camaro Yenko clone with a date coded correct 427, Muncie M22, 4:10 posi 12 bolt rear, a black 70 Chevelle SS454 LS5, Buckets, console, gauge package, Muncie M22, 3:73 12 bolt rear, Air, tilt, power windows and a black white stripe 07 Mustang GT500. I am saving for a Challenger Hellcat Redeye, Octane red. I am 61 and agree that the comfort, balance, beauty and power is what attracts me. It is not as fast as the new Camaro or Mustang around the race track but the sound and tire smoking power will put a grin on my face every time I crank it up and drive it. When I was 16 I had a chance to purchase a 68 Roadrunner coupe with a 383, 4 speed for $1600.00 but it fell through when the annual insurance was more than the cost of the car for a youngster like me. As you may guess I prefer Chevy but I never met a performance Dodge, Mustang or Chevy that I didn’t like.


#28

I have seen a stock 70 Buick Stage 1 out run a stock 70 Chevelle LS6.


#29

Thanks for the compliments on my SRT Challenger. It’s been a fun car and I really enjoy running it through the gears . My first Dodge.

You have a wonderful car collection!
What is the price point on the Redeye?

I’ve had Pontiacs nearly all my life. I have hung on to my favorite of a Lifetime for several decades. I’m the second owner. A ‘65 GTO, Montero Red/Black interior Coupe. It has never been driven in the rain since leaving the factory. It’s a 4 speed, Tripower Car, no power anything. Nearly all original. It’s a documented Ace Wilson’s Royal Bob Cat Car. Not many remain that are actual documented vehicles.
Good luck with your upcoming Redeye!


#30

I have to agree. I owned a 70 Challenger R/T SE convertible back in the day. The new Challenger comes closest to the look and spirit to the original.


#31

Glenn,

I don’t own a Mopar but I agree with you. The new Challenger does come closest to the original look and spirit of the original. But I am sure with many improvements.

I am seriously considering getting one in the first part of the new year. Just can’t make up my mind which one. Entry level, mid or performance? It is a matter of monthly cost. I’m sure I will regret it if I don’t go for the performance. Not Hell Cat or Demon but a worthy example.


#32

2018 Challenger Hellcat


#33

Hands down the Challenger…nuff said…


#34

Challenger as closest to original, but Mustang for the best re-do!!!
I’ve owned 21 Mustangs, best - "68 GT350 convert. Favorite vehicle - (produced) '70 'Cuda 440+6 convert. “Funest” - '26 T-bucket. Instant GONE!!!


#35

I always laugh at this debate about which late model retro style muscle car is best. The truth is if Ford has not developed the ‘05 Mustang, the Camaro AND Challenger would not even exist. Besides we all know what Steve McQ would drive.


#36

I hope that car makers in the near future start building actual replicas of these iconic shapes…I just recently started watching episodes of Miami Vice and my wife is really mad at me for pausing the recording just to point out a car of that era in the back ground…no matter how you look at them, having some looks from these car is one thing but having an exact spec original design but with todays tech on them would save all 3 companies…and maybe bring back a few…most of us seem to be looking for cars that were in our late teens and early 20’s…getting something before or after that may only be due till the year you were born…my dad swears up and down about the TRI 5’s he was born in 1939. I was born in 1962 and so those two icons years for cars would never go well with automakers but just think what they could do if it were possible…turn on the TRI 5 assembly line one week then switch over to the 80’s next week…I’d hold out for my 2 door 1979 Olds Cutlass , deep maroon, Carmel colored fake leather high back seats with magnesium rally wheels with white wall tires… Order me that and I’ll be happy to wait a few weeks for it MR. GM…


#37

Growing up in the 80’s, the Buick is my favorite of the bunch, but it seems to me that it isn’t really a modern car. The Dodge Challenger is my favorite of the new group, though the first of the new Mustangs are good looking as is the Camaro.


#38

I am a little partial to the current Mustang, owning a 17 GT350R does that to you, but… the Challenger is, as has been said a lot here, the best or closest to the original. The crazy horsepower aside it makes great noises and looks the part, very cool, the only issue I have is that there seems to be a lot of them. The Chevy is just a nothing look, the performance though of some of the models is right there. A good time to be around and capable of picking up something fun that you only have to keep clean and full of fuel to have lots of fun with…